Hacker News Reader

Comment by Nopoint2 | Hacker News Reader

There is just no reason to believe that we are born with some insanely big library of knowledge, and it sounds completely impossible. How would it be stored, and how would we even evolve it?

It just isn't needed. Just like you can find let's say kangaroos in the latent space of an image generator, so we learn abstract concepts and principles of how things work as a bonus of learning to process the senses.

Maybe a way to AGI could be figuring out how to combine a video generator with a LLM or something similar in a way that allows it to understand things intuitively, instead of doing just lots and lots of some statistical bullsit.

View on HN

> There is just no reason to believe that we are born with some insanely big library of knowledge, and it sounds completely impossible. How would it be stored, and how would we even evolve it?

We do have that, ever felt fear of heights? That isn't learned, we are born with it. Same with fear of small moving objects like spiders or snakes.

Such things are learned/stored very different from memories, but its certainly there and we can see animals also have those. Like cats gets very scared of objects that are long and appear suddenly, like a cucumber, since their genetic instincts thinks its a snake.

Of course it is learned, and fear is triggered by anything unfamiliar, that causes a high reconstruction error. Because it means you don't understand it, and it could be dangerous. We are just not used to encoding anything so deep below the eye level, and it freaks us out.

Do you really think every single ant is learning all that on its own? And if ants can store that in their DNA, why don't you think other animals can? DNA works just fine as generic information storage, there are obviously a ton of behaviors and information encoded there from hundreds of millions of years of survival of the fittest.

Yeah that's why people are terrified by white noise.

> Like cats gets very scared of objects that are long and appear suddenly, like a cucumber, since their genetic instincts thinks its a snake.

After having raised four dozen kittens that a couple of feral sisters gave birth to in my garage, I’m certain that is nonsense. It’s an internet meme that became urban legend.

I don’t think they have ever even reacted to a cucumber, and I have run many experiments because my childhood cat loved cucumbers (we’d have to guard the basket of cucumbers after harvest, otherwise she’d bite every single one of them… just once).

>How would it be stored, and how would we even evolve it?

DNA and the same way anything else is evolved? The body is insanely complicated, I don't see why innate knowledge is so unbelievable.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com