Ask HN: Are AI Agents a Lie? | Hacker News Reader

Ask HN: Are AI Agents a Lie?

2 pointsDavid12384 comments

LLMs awesome. They’ve changed how I code (Cursor), search for things, take notes, brainstorm, write emails, etc. (ChatGPT).

But I don’t use any AI agents. My friends don’t either. I haven’t even heard of any company building AI agents outside of the annoying customer service ones.

By AI agents I mean an LLM that does things in the background without needing constant feedback. Like booking a flight or scheduling a meeting.

The only useful “agentic” quality I’ve seen is basic file or web search to better answer my questions, which doesn’t feel like an agent.

Am I missing something? Why is there so much hype? Am I just understanding agents wrong?

IMHO most companies touting AI agent capabilities today are just participating in the hype cycle to get attention and funding. But don't let that lead you to think AI agents will never actually work. They are inevitably going to happen as a simple evolution of non-AI bots that already exist and have proven applications.

How capable and flexible agents will become and how cost-effective they will be is completely unknown. Cost is going to matter a ton. I'd love to just have an agent that constantly watches dashboards for me powered by o3 but I'd be bankrupt before the end of the day.

They are not a lie but useful agents that can take actions are still relatively rare. At MS Build this week I saw one that can write notion summaries of GitHub issues. I also saw one that actually resolved GitHub issues assigned to it. There’s lots more out there and little by little you’ll see them show up. The addition of MCP will help here as it gives “agents” the ability to connect to things and take action but within limits, therefore less likely to break stuff.

It's about trying to find a business model with high value so you can do "value based pricing". If you can replace a human salary you can charge a lot. If you are seen as just a chat bot, you can't.

https://www.wheresyoured.at/ has a lot to say about the topic.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com