Hacker News Reader

Comment by sarchertech | Hacker News Reader

My CS degree concentration is embedded systems. I love embedded programming, but it would probably cost me $200k a year to do it versus the backend distributed systems stuff I do now.

View on HN

Admittedly I don’t know your salary or market, but it is possible to make decent money in embedded. Connections & market timing are both vital though, in my experience, as well as being actually good at your job. I’m in Canada so numbers are way different, but salary-wise I’m in the ~75th percentile software engineers in my area, my title is embedded engineer, and I’m fairly junior (3 years out of university, ~6 years full-time experience). I’m working with some other embedded people who are in the 95th percentile for software engineers in the country. The main problem is there are very few high-paying embedded jobs; conversely though, there seem to be even fewer highly-skilled embedded engineers looking for work. I recently interviewed at a company paying 50th-85th (based on experience) percentile trying to hire pretty much any competent embedded engineer, and their problem isn’t insufficient salary, it’s just a lack of applicants or any skill level. From what I’ve heard, the same seems to be true pretty much everywhere.

Now sure, if you’re looking for 500k+ jobs, embedded isn’t the area to be in, unfortunately. But I prefer low-stress, fun-environment embedded jobs, and don’t mind trading off salary for that. Different strokes.

Problems like this always come down to salary. I love embedded (hardware in general, really) and would absolutely love to do it, but during my entire career, the salaries for embedded have been so much lower than you get for slinging JS/web shit. And now with 15 years in, the gap is even worse.

At this point, when I wanted to get back into hardware, it made more financial sense to outfit my home office with all the measuring instruments, debuggers, tools and other equipment necessary for embedded work and do it as a hobby. If I had the space, I could even get full-size CNC machines and still come out ahead cash wise. It’s insane.

It’s no wonder they can’t find experienced embedded devs, when it makes no financial sense to stick with it over a decade.

it is possible to get an embedded-adjacent job that pays well over 500k (my friend was bit banging FPGAs), it'll just be at an HFT instead of a car company

It’s definitely possible. There are probably a few embedded engineers making over $1M. But those are all outliers. It’s a whole lot easier to make $500k in web dev.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com