Hacker News Reader

Comment by billfruit | Hacker News Reader

Pictures are one way, there are other ways too like writing a journal.

Camera after all is a recent invention.

I do practice journaling, both on paper and digitally, been doing this for over 30 years. But there's nothing that can replace a video that I took from my grandpa where he would talk about his life's journeys for an hour, shortly before he developed alzheimers.

> Pictures are one way, there are other ways too like writing a journal.

Finding a shoebox full of photos is a lot easier to go through and reading through a journal / diary. One can quickly reminisce with the photos, but it would take a while to read through various written entries.

Photos can also capture spontaneous instants of time, whereas recollecting and writing down something involved taking up the entire context of an event and then 'interpreting' it so you can write it down.

Further, not all of one's internal state can even perhaps be put into words to be written down. A photo may help you recall feelings that you find difficult to put into words.

Few people have the time to sit and write a journal each day. I tried and it became a burden, a dread before bed time. Sleep won out.

Journals can also be electively subjective. Yes, a photo can be framed or posed, but it's harder to edit awkward truths out of a photo rather than omitting them from a journal.

People used to be always ready to scrible down things in the past I think, perhaps in the same way people are eager to take pictures now. Ofcourse one can't know before hand what's worth noting down and what's not, so I guess they would have just scribbled down everything, like when Plato wrote down what Socrates said.

"Few people have the time to sit and write a journal each day."

Yet many people seem to have the time to sink in endless time on Netflix, FB, Insta, candycrush or doomscrolling somewhere else.

Have you also noticed that the quality of people's handwriting is inversely proportional to the amount of time spent on these platforms?

( I have no data and I made this up)

I keep a journal. I write in it when there's something on my mind. I don't force myself to write in it every day, or at all, that would be ludicrous. Sometimes I write in it all of the time. Deep thoughts about life get indiscriminately mixed in with movie reviews, shopping lists and the fact that the name of the guy who unblocked the drains was Nigel. I write more than I read. Sometimes I search it for practical information (what was his name again?) which is why I keep it digital.

So if I really want to, I can find out how I was generally feeling in, say, 2006, and what sort of questions were on my mind and what ideas I had. Usually the answers are: pretty much the same, and stupid ones, kind of like today but worse. So it turns out that I don't want to review my journal much. But I only know that I don't want to because I have the option, so it has a reassuring function, and writing helps me think in the first place.

When it comes to photos, though, I'm with Ray Davies:

People take pictures of the Summer

Just in case someone thought they had missed it

And to prove that it really existed

People take pictures of each other

Just to prove that they really existed

Don't show me no more, please

It is not about having the time but prioritizing this time over something else.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com