Hacker News Reader

Comment by randyrand | Hacker News Reader

You can. It's not that hard to physically put a new chip on. Software people are too afraid to get their hands dirty.

De-soldering an MCU and soldering on a new oneis typically far from trivial. We're typically not talking about dedicated big through-hole flash chips here. We're often talking about MCUs with integrated flash memory which are surface-mounted and often with pins on the underside.

In general, I find it easier to desolder and replace surface mounted parts. With those, you just have to hit it with some hot air, it melts all the solder at once, and lifts right away. The chips are small, so it's not too bad to heat the whole thing evenly with a small air gun.

Through hole parts need a lot more heat across a bigger area, or you have to go pin by pin. I've scorched many a through hole board trying to desolder something, cursing at those who didn't socket the chip in the first place.

Want to annoy a repair person? Pot the whole thing in epoxy.

The saving grace here is that ESPs have radios and require certification which is expensive. As a result it is common for vendors to use pre-certified modules that are provided on a modular PCB with castellated half-holes. These are relatively easy to desolder.

For ESP these modules are the WROOM line.

Still easier than replacing the software on the chip, IMO.

This was about reusing the chip. Since these things are built using finite resources, maybe we should also design them with that reality in mind?

Usually in secure systems you can't read out all of the data from the old chip.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com