The Manicule: The little hand that's everywhere
messynessychic.com
messynessychic.com
Like that gorgeous orange (letterpress, I assume) manicule you see in the middle of OP - that line-work will never work when scaled down and put into a web page as a normal little manicule. The details get lost in a blur, the hand becomes a solid blob of black, it looks goofy and out of place (note: for the mouse pointer, this is a feature, not a bug), or it ceases to look like a hand at all to someone who isn't primed for it by an article.
I can tell you that because I tried one that looked a lot like that. I went through literally hundreds of manicules from Wikimedia Commons, Font Awesome, Google Images, and articles like this, trying dozens of them on my actual website, and it took that long to find a single one I was at all happy with in context. I was shocked. No other icon I use on my site was that hard to find an adequate version of. (We really wanted a manicule for our use-case, so we persevered.)
Ones I always find it difficult to find good icons for are "users/people" and "save file".
As someone who knows very little about iconography and design, this is very surprising to me. I thought that the "floppy disk for save" (or "downward arrow to a horizontal line for download") conventions were pretty universal, and probably have tons of implementations to choose from. What aspects have you found challenging?
https://bibliothek.univie.ac.at/virtuelle-ausstellungen/file...
Well worth playing if you are interested in history, probably even if games aren't normally your thing. It is a real gem.