Hacker News Reader

Comment by gruez | Hacker News Reader

>Maybe they got it from an LLM, maybe they didn't, but what matters is the college sophomore level of consideration of the individual tariffs.

Sounds like we're in agreement? The tariffs are badly thought out, but the "lol they got their policy from LLMs" accusation is entirely spurious.

View on HN

I think so, but I'm not actually sure that any of the realities that would have lead to this outcome is any less embarrassing for the administration. Because there is real information contained in the fact that pretty much every LLM gives roughly the same answer— it doesn't help that the wording is similar either. Does it mean that they used an LLM? No not really, but it does strongly imply that their formula and the source for it are the "StackOverflow answer" for lack of a better term.

And while it's not wrong I guess it's also the kind of thing that you would expect to use for your econ homework than a real application of policy. I don't think it's unreasonable to assume that the person who made this spreadsheet really did do something to the effect of type "how to calculate reciprocal tariffs" into Google. And that's not a bad thing necessarily if you're a rando who's just been tasked with figuring that out but you couldn't have found someone with more experience with actually doing this and modeling the economic effects?

I think that it's a testament to the genuinely breakneck speeds they been trying to get policy out there that it's been so slapdash.

I really don't think this is entirely spurious considering Elon has been using LLMs to fire government employees. It seems like a very plausible explanation for how they came up with this policy.

>Elon has been using LLMs to fire government employees

Source?

from Mike Johnson, about DOGE's use of algorithms: ""Elon has cracked the code. He is now inside the agencies. He’s created these algorithms that are constantly crawling through the data. And as he told me in his office, the data doesn’t lie. We’re going to be able to get the information."

My speculation, but it's very likely that one of those pieces of analyzed information was the 5 bullet points from each federal employee justifying their job.

https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/donald-trump/live-blog/trum...

https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/doge/federal-workers-agenci...

Is Elon really that stupid?

Just because doesn't lie doesn't mean we understand it correctly.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com