Ask HN: Don't you think vibe-coding is a marketing scheme? | Hacker News Reader

Ask HN: Don't you think vibe-coding is a marketing scheme?

5 pointssonderotis6 comments

It seems more like a meme.

Reminds me of the "10x Developer" memes I used to see. "10x Developer doesn't have time to explain things." "10x Developer doesn't have time for pleasantries."

I thought it was a joke, but people were serious ... 10x Developer label sounded just an excuse for being an asshole...

I haven’t seen anything about “vibe coding” that indicated to me the person using the term was a serious person.

saw on linkedin. some ai company is starting a vibecoding course.

I feel like most of what I see on LinkedIn doesn’t happen / is just talk so I don’t know what to make of that.

Although there is lots of hype, vibe-coding isn't a marketing gimmick—it's just continuing the trend we've always followed: moving to higher levels of abstraction. Like going from assembler to C made life better by letting us focus on logic instead of registers, vibe-coding means taking that next leap, writing code that directly captures 'what' rather than 'how.' When the specification becomes executable, there's less room for misinterpretation and fewer bugs, and your mental effort can shift from managing low-level details to clearly expressing your intent. It's not magic; it's just the natural evolution toward clearer, safer, and more maintainable code. It's not there yet, but, just as C++ replaced C which replaced assembler, "specification as code" is the future for most software. Eventually, most of us will be "prompt engineers" rather than "software engineers".

"and your mental effort can shift from managing low-level details to clearly expressing your intent."

I really struggle to understand what people are doing that makes these two things mutually exclusive. Unless the catchment group is people who can't code or understand software engineering. Which is fine. It reminds me a lot of the no-code hype.

I wonder if ai-coding will turn out a bit like ultra processed food. Cheap to produce something that looks like it does the job, but actually is quite bad for consumers.

I don't see anyone producing objective measures on the improved apps. Like bugs per lines if code, feature development time, etc.

Not a marketing scheme, although scheming marketers have start to notice and ramp that up. Vibe-coding is a small fad coming from the overly enthusiastic.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com