Ask HN: Would You Pay for an AI-Powered Speech Therapy App for Kids? | Hacker News Reader

Ask HN: Would You Pay for an AI-Powered Speech Therapy App for Kids?

1 pointts12136 comments

Hey HN,

I'm working on LingoPaws, an AI-powered speech training app for kids struggling with articulation. Unlike traditional speech therapy, it provides real-time feedback, gamified practice, and AI-generated exercises tailored to each child's speech patterns.

We’re testing whether parents (or even speech therapists) would find value in this before scaling. The biggest problem we’re solving: speech therapy is expensive, limited in availability, and often not engaging for kids.

Would you pay for an app like this?

If you're a parent, would you subscribe for $10-20/month if it helps your child improve faster?

If you're a speech therapist, would you use it as a tool to complement therapy?

Do you think this approach solves a real problem, or is there a better way to tackle it?

We have a basic prototype and a waitlist for early access: https://www.lingopaws.com/en

Would love your feedback, especially from those who have experience in edtech, AI, or speech therapy!

I am a parent but don't currently have a need for this. Looking at your site I would currently not subscribe if I did have a need. It's unclear how much processing will be done on device and how much will be done in the cloud. It's also unclear what data retention policies you have. I don't want to read the privacy policy to figure this out. I'd expect an explanation on the overview of what data will be stored, how long, and how it will be managed since this will involve recordings of my child. I also think a third party audit of your code and privacy practices would be helpful, but I understand this isn't something you may want to do initially while the app is changing significantly in early development.

Thanks! Your point about making privacy clearer on the site is super helpful.

And what kind of on-device vs. cloud processing balance would make you feel comfortable? Also, would a transparent settings panel where you control what data is stored and for how long help?

Would love to hear from others how important are privacy guarantees and local processing when considering an AI-powered speech training tool for kids?

No.

Your app might gamify speech practice, but it overlooks crucial elements: nuanced human judgment, emotional rapport, and adaptive interpersonal communication. Speech therapists don’t just correct sounds; they navigate psychological nuances, adjust dynamically based on subtle cues, and foster genuine motivation through trust. AI might imitate, but can’t authentically replicate this.

Parents wary of therapy’s cost and engagement issues might initially bite, but sustained improvement demands personalised professional insight. Edtech and AI thrive as complements, not replacements.

Reframe your positioning clearly as a supplemental practice tool, not a replacement for professional therapy, or risk selling parents a mirage.

Thanks for your sharing.

I completely agree that AI can’t replace a trained speech therapist. My goal is to bridge the gap between sessions, giving children more frequent and engaging practice opportunities.

Right now, many kids only see a therapist once a month. I think the app can be an AI-powered supplemental tool that provides gamified speech exercises to reinforce what they learn in therapy.

Would reframing our wordings to emphasize this "complementary" role make it clearer?

Would love to hear more from you.

Ah, I thought you were proposing something to use as an alternative to traditional speech therapy.

It depends on whether or not such a thing would be effective, honestly. I'd want to see some data on that.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com