Hacker News Reader

Comment by tylermenezes | Hacker News Reader

Everyone's focusing on the security of the password and iCloud, but I just wanted to take a second to say: fuck who did this. Yes he should have backups, but erasing someone's things is such a juvenile thing to enjoy.

Edit: Surprised to see Cloudflare is proxying their website. I understand wanting to be impartial, but I think it's fairly easy to draw the line at groups breaking the law.

View on HN

erasing someone's things is such a juvenile thing to enjoy

I don't know what part of the world you're in, but here (in the UK) it'd actually be a criminal offense carrying a multi-year prison sentence under the Computer Misuse Act.

I'm wondering at what point the police or law enforcement get involved in the US?

Generally if the person is important enough.

This is the only case I can think of where non-classified information leaks were prosecuted: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sarah_Palin_email_hack (There are probably more, but I can't imagine any would actually disprove my point.)

This isn't solely about an information leak, though -- it's about willful destruction of property (i.e. all the victim's data getting vaped).

Usually the FBI is the agency that you go to with this stuff, and they usually don't help unless you can claim X hundreds of thousands of dollars in losses. Basically, they only care about rich people and corporations. Hackers are given a blank cheque so long as they only do small amounts of financially quantifiable damage.

As with so many other things in the United States, it is de facto only a crime if it happens to someone rich or well-connected. Mr. Honan is probably on the bubble, there. If it happened to me, a no-namer with skimpy assets, the thought of the FBI getting involved would be a punchline.

I'm sure most feel bad for the guy, but although the hacker's actions were malicious, that doesn't allow the victim to just get off the hook for having a silly password - if that was the case.

He didn't "get off the hook". His files got wiped.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com