Hacker News Reader

Comment by easygenes | Hacker News Reader

Why in the world am I getting downvoted for this? For the Claude summary? I also checked the repository manually, and agree with the summary. One of the prime use cases for LLMs is summarization.

View on HN

No one cares. If I wanted to know what an LLM thinks, I'd ask it myself.

Your comment should not be flagged. It is useful info. I wrote the Reg article and I submitted the link, and I didn't know about the update project.

However, I do agree with the other commenters -- do not paste LLM bot output. Your own summary was better.

Didn’t downvote you, but I don’t see any value in posting a copy/paste from Claude.

You’re not saving me any meaningful time or doing something I couldn’t. It is not worth a post IMO

The main point of the post is to say that it is getting maintained in a fork now, to some degree. It's still a very rudimentary implementation though.

This summary was much better (shorter and to the point) than Claude’s ;)

I feel the same way about people who post a link to/paragraph from Wikipedia, but people don't reflexively downvote those.

Please don't litter HN with LLM generated slop. The value of HN lies in the human discussion, everyone here is capable of asking an LLM about it.

Maybe you should ask an LLM?

It would be extremely cool if this weren't the case, but current LLMs are just very bad at summarization. As evidenced by the slop you posted being a bad summary!

Reply on news.ycombinator.com