What's the user base like in these games? I feel like every FOSS FPS I've ever played, besides UrbanTerror, has few to no players.
It's very fast paced and requires quite a lot of skill and muscle memory to become good at it. There are a couple of "noob" servers that are quite enjoyable however. Overall a very good game.
There's a pretty fun FOSS FPS called AssaultCube which I used to play a lot - it's simple but it's fun. That has quite a high number of players. Unsure about how active the other FPSs are but whenever I've tried them out I've always been able to get a game.
Disclosure: I'm on the Xonotic core team :)
But somehow UT feels very much like a community. More so, than the other ones. (i like world-of-padman though)