As I noted, this post is saying AI can't achieve "genius" level creativity. Just a year ago the criticisms were that it couldn't match a human. How is that not moving the goalposts?
I agree entirely this is annoying.
This case is different because there is no claim that we don't have AI, nor a claim that once we get that we will have AI.
Instead it's a very specific discussion of a particular weakness of current AI systems (that few would disagree with) and some thoughts about a roadmap for progress.