Hacker News Reader

The man in charge of the British response to the great hunger was Charles Trevelyan. He famously said of the Irish "[The Famine] is a punishment from God for an idle, ungrateful, and rebellious country; an indolent and un-self-reliant people. The Irish are suffering from an affliction of God's providence."

The British actively exported grains meats and other food leaving the local population to starve.

It was a famine only because they made it one.

View on HN

He also famously suggested that the Irish should simply grow corn, if there was a potato blight. As if, in the middle of a famine, farmers can simply pivot to another crop that they've never grown before.

I don’t think Ireland grows corn today. The wiki page for Irish agriculture doesn’t even mention it, which I interpret as “not enough grown to be noteworthy”.

We grow maize, which is what we call corn, here. In significant quantities, using modern agricultural methods. Even with that the climate is not totally suitable and it is mostly used for animal feed.

I very much doubt it would have been possible to grow sustainable amounts of maize up until recent decades

And unless something changes with corn strains and agriculture, possibly not again in another four or five. It's a very thirsty boy. Both in water and nitrogen.

It wasn't a famine - it was a genocide

Reply on news.ycombinator.com