Hacker News Reader

Hacker News

Comment by sedatk | Hacker News Reader

Full thread

sedatk

If the author reads this: John Carmack's last name was mistyped as "Carnmack" throughout the document.

View on HN

Thank you for taking the time to report it. It has now been fixed.

Another typo s/game/gave/: "Another reason John game me".

Speaking of Carmack, can you (or someone) elaborate on this quote?

>DOOM cycles between three display pages. If only two were used, it would have to sync to the VBL to avoid possible display flicker.

How does triple buffering eliminate VBL waits, exactly? There was no VBL interrupt on a standard VGA, was there?

Triple buffering mean you can render at any speed, there will always be a valid target where to render and you never need to wait or vsync.

This is not the case with double buffering. There can be a case, if the CPU renders fast enough, where it just finished rendering to the current target, but the previous target is still being sent to the CRT. In that case the CPU need to block on VBL.

Sure, that part is well understood. But triple buffering doesn't avoid the need for vsync. If the VBL interrupt isn't reliably available on all the VGA cards out there, you are still going to have flip pages from the foreground at some point, and you would rather not do that outside the blanking interval.

I suppose you could poll the CRTC every so often during the game loop or rendering process, though. That must have been how it worked.

The CRTC latches the display start address at the beginning (IIRC) of vblank, so you can just write a new value to that register at any time without affecting the current frame.

There was a vbl interrupt: https://gamedev.stackexchange.com/questions/206442/dos-vga-c...

Not something reliable enough to use in a shipping product, apparently.

I imagine that a GPU-only "select this buffer when the next frame happens" would be better supported, even if the CPU doesn't get told when. Or even if you can't get an interrupt, you could poll periodically, etc.

That's already how it works on the VGA, you write the start address into a CRTC register and it will be used once the next frame starts, without affecting the current one.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com