Hacker News Reader

It's always interesting to follow the discussions on PPRuNe https://www.pprune.org/accidents-close-calls/664303-delta-cr...

Unverified reports by another pilot are that the plane struck a wing then sort of cart wheeled

View on HN

Here's some better footage https://www.reddit.com/r/aviation/comments/1is1qoy/video_of_...

I don't think the "wing struck ground" is really an accurate description based on this footage.

Indeed. Likely a wing tip strike, the right wing was ripped off, then the left wing is of course still flying so its lifting force rolls the plane over until that wing hits the ground. I think it stayed attached, so after that, the plane just slid to a stop. Edit: Saw a video, looks like the pilot flying failed to flare so they just hit the ground really hard but wings level, probably the landing gear collapsed. Not clear what caused the right wing to be removed. In any case, the plane left the frame so you couldn’t see what happened next.

Too late to edit further, but I should add that there could be many reasons for the apparent failure to flare. I did not intend to speculate that the pilot is to blame. That is for the crash investigators to figure out.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com