First off, keep in mind im going towards a pretty small niche here - people that will actually spend time on my app are power users. Gamers who are into tech, and want options.
There are alot of video options, but given my resources this was the optimal solution IMO - and not being modest, I think its a pretty novel solution.
The "huge" sidebar was my solution to not much real estate to put quality vids, while still giving flexability to break down a replay. I could hide the controls, but it does take away a bit of flex (if u want to rewind one player for example). My target audience is people who are good with computers.
I do like the single stream idea however, I can work on that in the future.
After playing with the site a while, I noticed the sidebar and it all fits now. I think the initial problem is that nobody's done multiple POVs before, so once people get the hang of it they'll want more.
+1 to the single multiplexed stream (at least to start with).
+1 to annotations tagged to specific seek times (if needed).