Hacker News Reader

The idea that graphite may contain in inclusions that are superconducting at room temperature is highly speculative (putting it mildly) and not an idea that is taken seriously in the condensed matter physics community.

View on HN

Possibly, but a lot of real progress has been made by trying things that turn out to work and then working backwards to figure out how.

If this ever works/worked I would agree, but the linked paper is not at all convincing.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com