Comment by breakds | Hacker News Reader

Comment by breakds | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

Yes, we are in the U.S., but our situation seems quite different from the standard RSU process you described.

We did not receive a W-2, and the company has not reported the RSUs as taxable income yet.

Even though our RSUs fully vested at IPO, they are not yet settled as shares—the company has set the settlement date to March 15, 2025.

The company is requiring us to prepay withholding taxes in cash before they release the shares. If we don’t pay by the deadline, the RSUs will be forfeited entirely.

This is why we are trying to better understand how this aligns with U.S. tax laws and whether this is standard practice.

We agree that this doesn’t sound like how RSUs typically work in the U.S., which is why we are seeking advice. If you have any thoughts on how this situation might fit within U.S. tax regulations, we’d really appreciate your perspective!

I talked to someone who is a Chief Accounting Officer. First off, to be perfectly blunt, you were foolish to wait until 30 days before this occurred before asking questions.

The company has an obligation to withhold tax to the IRS. It sounds like the company doesn't want to spend its own cash to pay this withholding tax so they are forcing ex-employees to fork over the cash, with the threat of forfeiting their shares.

This doesn't sound legal unless it was spelled out in your employee equity grant. The fact that you would forfeit your shares seems wrong. I would read over whatever equity grants you signed.

However the benefit is that you get 100% of your shares and you don't lose any shares to taxes. You could talk to a lawyer but unless you don't have the money to pay the withholding tax (22% of the opening price of the shares on the settlement date unless you own more than $1 million, which then becomes 37%), I would just pay as little as possible and get the shares.

If it is legal, it's the company being an asshole and being really shitty to their ex-employees. Please name and shame them so that we can avoid them.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com