> "A people without history Is not redeemed from time, for history is a pattern Of timeless moments. So, while the light fails On a winter's afternoon, in a secluded chapel History is now and England."
Asking an LLM about this verse, it seems to understand history is a pattern and that history is used to predict the next event in a sequence but it really doesn't understand the significance of the author writing "History is now and England."
I agree with this output:
> In essence, the stanza argues that history—composed of key, enduring moments—is vital for redemption and identity. Without it, a people are lost in time. This concept parallels how LLMs work: by analyzing and learning from historical (past) data, they identify patterns that allow them to generate future text. While LLMs don’t “predict the future” in a prophetic sense, understanding and leveraging patterns—much like those in history—enables them to produce output that reflects continuity, context, and nuance.
Thus, while the poem and LLMs operate in very different realms (human experience vs. statistical computation), both rely on the idea that recognizing patterns from the past is crucial to shaping or anticipating what comes next.
Do you see this destroying prediction-based markets (i.e. the stock market and Polymarket)?
Markets exist because there's uncertainty about the future. If LLMs can predict with extremely high accuracy, would there no longer be a need for markets?
I think you could simply shift the market 6 months in the future. no prediction system will be perfect for arbitrarily long horizons at reasonable cost.
It is one thing to predict the future and have everyone not know about the predictions, but in a world where many people will be able to use LLMs to predict the future, the lower the quality of the predictions will be because they won't take into account that there are other agents predicting the future, which would influence the action of those agents, so you end up in a game theory scenario not that dissimilar from what we have now
Do you plan to share the source code to see if we could replicate this?
But we have free/very very low tiers for academia.
So in case you need access for your research, go to https://www.newscatcherapi.com/free-news-api
Or feel free to email me directly at artem@newscatcherapi.com