Hacker News Reader

Comment by zamalek | Hacker News Reader

Wayland has support for games completely taking over the GPU; notoriously critical for VR support. This is basically the same as Windows exclusive full screen.

Wine/proton would need to support it, XWayland would need to support it (Wine/Proton are one major step away from native Wayland support: Vulkan), and finally the compositor would need to support it. Gnome is about the worst compositor that you could be testing any of this stuff on, they are comically hostile towards ideas not their own. The chances of this ever working on Gnome are near zero. KDE is pretty good for support, Hyprland seems to be trying to support every under the sun.

View on HN

> notoriously critical for VR support. This is basically the same as Windows exclusive full screen.

D3D12 dropped support for exclusive fullscreen, and I don't think headsets even go through DXGI but their own swap chain APIs. Why do VR games on Linux need the equivalent from the Wayland compositor?

VR on X.Org also already bypasses the X server for the VR display.

Can I have the source for this? DX12 dropped exclujsive FS? Why does every game still has this as a option then? Or are you talking about VR specifically?

Sure, I took it from the docs [1].

Games may show it as an option if the engine itself can support other GPU APIs and the devs working on the options menu don't know or care that this particular settings combination is misleading.

[1]: https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/win32/direct3d12/s...

> Gnome is about the worst compositor that you could be testing any of this stuff on, they are comically hostile towards ideas not their own. The chances of this ever working on Gnome are near zero.

GNOME has supported direct scanout for fullscreen apps for a while and drm-lease was implemented not too long ago either.

Did not know Wayland has exclusive FS.

I doubt that Wine would actually request it. Some compositors also have "tearing mode," which is basically as good: the game gets full control of the presentation timing, so vsync/tearing would be determined by what the game wants to do.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com