Ask HN: Do technical interviewers feel guilty about their hard questions? | Hacker News Reader

Ask HN: Do technical interviewers feel guilty about their hard questions?

3 pointsamichail10 comments

One might expect this, especially for those trying to identify candidates with high inherited intelligence, in an age of AI where such intelligence might be less important.

View on HN

Why should anyone feel guilty about asking hard/difficult questions? It's not always about what you know but about your ability to stop and think, or in some cases to admit you can't answer the question. The last one isn't a sign of weakness but it is a sign of self awareness and the recognition that your knowledge and experience has limits.

Would you test a candidate's unaided vision or hearing? Would you want them to admit that they can't see the tiny print or hear the faint sound?

I ask hard questions to see how you handle them. One of the most important things you can say in a technical interview is "I don't know". You can't know everything, and how you handle running off the end of your knowledge says a lot.

Why would they? Hard questions are useful. The purpose of an interview is to determine whether you would want to have the candidate as a co-worker. For a technical interview, that means you want to understand how they approach problems and communicate about their thinking and solutions. In order to watch someone at work, you need to give them some actual work to do, which means that the problem you set must be hard enough to require genuine effort.

Easy questions would be a waste of everyone's time.

Why would intelligence be less important?

Because the combined intelligence of an intelligent but non-genius human and highly intelligent AI might be really good.

You need baseline intelligence to be able to make effective use of AI tools.

Sure, but maybe you get diminishing returns with higher human IQ at some point.

Tip: it’s that you’re a pain in the ass, not higher IQ.

High EQ people learn to “smooth”. (I’m not one off those.) Intelligent intelligent people know it is the convenient relationship that sells. Problem solvers who do not make others pay for their idiosyncrasies are and forever shall be in demand.

Nope. It’s all really to feel you out. There are many considerations for a well suited candidate, how one handles being put on the spot is one of them.

Besides, if you really think it’s the smarties who are no longer necessary, there may be other things you’re missing that “tell” during these interviews.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com