Hacker News Reader

Comment by maxglute | Hacker News Reader

Well it's more... Xiaohongshu is for cosmo PRC cool kids (read: lean wealthy), and also a large ecommerce portal that targets that demographic. Not sure if the userbase is interested in... western and RoW "riff raff" shitting up the content for too long. I say this more as an insult to Xiaohongshu, I like TikTok (or Douyin) because I like seeing entrepenurs sell neon signs and industrial glycerine between my swipes.

View on HN

"Hey Homie, it's Tony,"

I've never been so interested in advertisements for commercial equipment before that guy.

His accent is fascinating. It's like he learned English as a second language in Rural Georgia.

And that's only one of his accents. The man is a chameleon.

Rest of World had an informative article about Xiaohongshu few months ago, it seems indeed to be a combination of Instagram and Tripadvisor. Chinese people that are able to travel are using it to find the "authentic" places.

https://restofworld.org/2024/xiaohongshu-southeast-asia-tour...

It's also TIGHTLY controlled, with people complaining on Twitter and elsewhere that their posts are under 48 hour review before posting. The rules are also quite strict around LGBT issues etc, and not in favor.

Most of all though it's just a very silly protest, given that the "tiktok ban bill" is really a "hostile foreign-power controlled platform divestment bill" so Xiaohongshu will just be next on the block in the unlikely event that it becomes popular.

> cosmo PRC cool kids (read: lean wealthy)

What does this mean?

well-traveled kids from well-connected families

XHS is for cool GenZ, bias female, urban, has money / disposable income, think coastal elite. I guess more lifestyle/gram, pushes beauty, fashion, wellness, food, luxury goods etc. Douyin (TikTok) is for masses... "less cultured" audience, more working class / hillbilly, pushes some of the above occasionally but also everything else from cheap widgets to industrial equipment.

Or the Chinese version of instagram, by short

Not really. Little Redbook is like if everyone on Reddit was upper middle class instead of Reddit's low middle class. Plus Instagram daily life and friend photos. Plus TikTok algorithm videos. Plus Tumblr microblogging. We don't have a 1:1 equivalent.

Reddit, except upper middle class, is how HN feels to me a lot of the time.

For more down to earth contents I heard that Kuaishou (They made KLING AI video maker) is more suitable.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com