Hacker News Reader

Comment by lmm | Hacker News Reader

> This can be a "physical person" (eg a freelance activity), depending on the country, but that still requires registration

Not necessarily. Many countries do not require sole proprietors to be registered.

> if it's millions per year, it's usually a terrible idea to do it as a freelancer.

In the US with its liability lawsuit culture yes. Elsewhere operating as a sole proprietor is not always such a terrible idea.

> That banked entity needs to be incorporated, or treatable as a corporation.

It really doesn't.

View on HN

>In the US with its liability lawsuit culture yes. Elsewhere operating as a sole proprietor is not always such a terrible idea.

It's a terrible idea because as a non-American you can easily hire a firm like Appleby to evade nearly all taxes if you're rolling in millions.

It's a terrible idea because in most countries, it's much more expensive to pay yourself as a freelance than operate a corporation than can easily reinvest profits into itself.

It's not even "hiring a firm like Appleby". It's "hiring an accountant". Paying $1-2k a year to save yourself hundreds of thousands in difference.

And yes if you're hoping to process payments on Stripe, you need to be banked, and the banked entity will undergo KYB. I have no idea why you're denying this. Is this some sort of gaslighting nonsense?

> in most countries, it's much more expensive to pay yourself as a freelance than operate a corporation than can easily reinvest profits into itself.

Maybe. I've found people in my country tend to assume a corporation has stuff to spend on and/or be doing expenses fraud, and actually if you're doing things properly the all-in tax rate is potentially worse for a corporation by the time you actually have the money in your personal account.

> if you're hoping to process payments on Stripe, you need to be banked, and the banked entity will undergo KYB.

Perhaps, but you absolutely don't need to be a corporation for that. You give them your name and (personal) tax number and maybe a one-line description of what business you're in and that's that.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com