Seems a bit picky. If the bot has seen the exact problem before it's not really doing anything more than recall to solve it.
(There was also a much earlier piece of software that would generate semi-intelligible Kant or Hegel one sentence at a time, though that was through a series of a priori generation rules and a large at the time dictionary of stock phrases. I wonder what ever happened to that.)
The problem is just that people keep insisting that those things are intelligent.