US-based ultra runner arrested in India for carrying Garmin InReach

advnture.com

17 points·harambae··9 comments

It will be interesting to see how the Indian authorities react now that every new cell phone is a satellite communications terminal.

Like Israel did 15 years ago with Kindle/iPads: upon arrival you give up your device for "safekeeping" and pick it up as you leave the country.

So the presumption is that the device is illegal because it allows communications?

The device is illegal because the government deems satellite communication to be illegal. Like Starlink is illegal in India.

Why are satellite communications banned in these countries?

It's the usual government incompetence and paranoia. They're afraid that people will use satellite communications to coordinate protests or violence. India has routinely cut off Internet and cellular access in some regions.

https://www.dw.com/en/india-internet-shutdown-capital-of-the...

Such a B.S. statement from her: "I was not aware a GPS device was illegal"

This has nothing to do with GPS, she's just saying GPS to gain sympathy. It the satellite communications.

The article is even dumb, who writes these things: "Small, rugged and lightweight, this satellite communicator enables two-way text messaging using GPS technology, even in areas with no cell coverage."

GPS is one way technology, how does GPS allow two way text messaging?

It was a Garmin InReach device... ... and there's no reason random visitors would assume that's illegal.

I know it was an InReach, I just find the article B.S. by saying the issue was the GPS not the Satellite communication. Or you can have two way text messaging via GPS.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com