Hacker News Reader

Hacker News

Comment by latexr | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

latexr

> stupid geographical restrictions

DVDs had those too.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DVD_region_code

> they tend to limit quality, both for copyright and traffic saving purposes

As long as the quality is above 480p, it’s still better than DVD.

View on HN

I consider streaming 720p to be DVD quality at best. (And no, i'm not basing that on bitrate. I know modern compression is much better.)

> I consider streaming 720p to be DVD quality at best.

But it’s not, DVD quality is 480p. This isn’t a matter of opinion, we can look up the numbers.

That's too simple a comparison, against something that's a little more complicated. A 720p stream without adequate bandwidth can have terrible artifacts, mostly showing up during fast motion/panning/action. They can look objectively worse than DVDs.

That's similar to saying that a 20 megapixel front facing camera of a cheap chinese phone is superior to a 12 megapixel DLSR.

You're right that vertical resolution is just one factor, but streaming uses radically more efficient codecs than DVD, so at typical broadband speeds, streaming 480P on YouTube will look far better than DVD did.

That's not even close to true, WTF. YouTube 480p has criminally low bitrate, even the crappiest DVDs have better quality.

I encourage you to try it. Because I wasn't sure, I already had (using the new 28 Years Later trailer) before I posted. You can use yt-dlp to see that the 480P YouTube version is AV1 at 572 Kbps, which is notably better than a DVD Video-compliant MPEG-2 encode from the highest quality source available.

Wikipedia say that "Typically, the data rate for DVD movies ranges from 3 to 9.5 Mbit/s" [1] which is much more than 572 Kbit/s. The Youtube quality issues are easy to spot on highly dynamic clips (with fireworks, flashing lights etc).

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DVD-Video

Yeah, but switching to downscaled 4k streams on my 1080p TV was at least as big a jump as upgrading the set from 720p to 1080p.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com