Hacker News Reader

2. I sign a dance all the time with my kid. have also been to tens of concerts where various artist sanged and danced. this comment makes no sense at all…

Oh, I'm sure you can walk and sing, too. A waltz and sing, probably. But when you're dancing hard enough to sweat? Naaah.

Just for fun tomorrow, go out for a jog and try to sing.

That's how professional musicians workout. See Beyonce for example:

https://www.thethings.com/how-does-beyonce-sing-and-dance-at...

The extreme effort she has to go through to make it work proves my point.

Proves your point "Nobody can sing and dance simultaneously" :) :) :) :)

I would respond to this if I thought you were not serious :)

Musical Theater would like a word with you.

Haha, try jogging and talking at the same time.

There's a youtube channel analysing exactly that: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k8rMNMURShM&pp=ygUiZmlsIHdpb...

Yes on 1 no on 2. Especially if you consider moshing etc dancing. Hell you'll hear them suck air sometimes when they're skanking around the stage.