Hacker News Reader

Comment by dartharva | Hacker News Reader

Murderbot frequently blends into the crowd as a dude though, that's a recurring theme in the series.

> Murderbot frequently blends into the crowd as a dude though, that's a recurring theme in the series.

Murderbot blends as a human. Can you remember a specific passage where it's a dude? It could be your brain playing tricks on you.

I'm a man and I'm guilty of assuming a male gender for characters where the text says "a guard", "a doctor", "a soldier", etc. When I was told some readers thought Murderbot was female, I re-read several passages and nowhere does Martha Wells state its gender either way (even by stating Murderbot passes for a man or woman).

I'm with you, my recollection is that the author worked hard to not apply a gender, and I think I just visualized the bot as an actual android with no gender, but when the casting happened I realized at some point I assumed female in there. Best guess is that I applied the author's gender onto the first-person perspective of the character.

Yes, I was surprised by all the people here who had a female mental picture for this reason. While obviously it is genderless, my recollection was that there were plenty of times where the narrative had it passing as male.

I'll say I've only read the first ... uh... three? four? novellas, and it's been many moons. I don't recall any point where having a female form would've been noteworthy. Not like a /Stomship Troopers/ shared shower moment or anything.

Mainly I think we came up with that mindset immediately upon reading the first novella and never updated it.

It's entirely possible that there's never any point where "observed gender" is even implied and my mind just filled in some blanks when it talks about passing for human. To be honest I never gave it an ounce of thought before this whole conversation.

I think that's what happened. Your mind filled in the gaps and assumed Murderbot's gender.

I'm pretty sure it's never stated it looks like either a man or a woman. I mean, if it can pass for human it must like either or at least androgynous, but Martha Wells never tells us which.

Quite possible. To loop back to my first post, my point was I could have sworn there were at least strong implications at times that it was male-coded, although without gender. But perhaps it is just my own personal mandela effect.

What I do find interesting though is how many people chimed in here with a very strong sense of this detail but it was all a mix of responses! :)

where?

I'm willing to believe you are right, but not without someone finding the text to indicate as such. I do not recall this being the case, but I've only read the first two.

I checked and I don't think so. Artificial Condition includes "blending in" as someone of "indeterminate" gender named "Eden" with longer-than-short hair and longer-than-normal eyebrows, which seems to be a careful non-gendered description.

I remember Murderbot working to blend in and pass as human, but I don't remember it trying to pass as male or being perceived as male?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com