Fair points, but the fact is that the app was selling more when it was visible in search. When it dropped out of search, it stopped selling.
In my opinion, considering how many timer apps there are in the App Store already, making $5k in a little over a month is a pretty good result. That's a nice little passive income stream of $127/day for an app he probably doesn't have to put that much more work into (although I don't think those numbers will be sustainable).