And live has the big advantage that it cannot be re-recorded, so it's more natural and not as rehearsed as a recorded video.
This is very true in my case because I’m dyslexic so I ingest context more easily when heard vs when read.
For other people, it might just be a personal preference. Just like you have the personal preference to read rather than watch.
Arguing that the GP has some major character flaw because of their own personal preference really says more about your own character than it does theirs.
Turns out, people have only so much working memory, but are good at covering for it with emotions.
You’ll see demos from colleagues in different departments who you might not normally work with. And individuals praised for specific wins.
A good all hands should be for the staff, not for the execs. And that’s the harder skill execs need to learn: when to stfu and let their staff have screen time.
If all hands is done well, it brings the business closer and motivates employees in ways that an email couldn’t. However this is lost on most execs and so all hands often ends up being an ego trip for themselves, and when that happens the thats when things need to be communicated via email.
Also it's not personal preference. If you're an executive you need to know how to write properly. Execs rely on oral communication to use their charisma points on you, when you read the plans many times they have nothing to do with what was said or it's much simpler. Same with politicians.
It’s about uniting everyone emotionally as well as academically.
The emotional component is an absolutely a critical part.
And this is one of the tells for a company that cares about staff moral verses those that don’t. One that care make their all hands about the employees too.
People ingest info differently, and being able to communicate the same info in multiple ways should be table stakes at that level.
Giving them anything is the wrong move. If you think you are getting as much out of the video as they are getting out of you watching them speak, you are wrong. The degree of wrong depends on your affinity with their chosen craft (which is, to be clear, grifting you).