Hacker News Reader

Comment by crabmusket | Hacker News Reader

As far as I can tell, multiplayer is the killer app for Durable Objects. If you want to build another Figma, Google Docs, etc, the programming model of Durable Objects is super handy.

This article goes into it more: https://digest.browsertech.com/archive/browsertech-digest-cl...

I think this old article is quite relevant too: http://ithare.com/scaling-stateful-objects/

Anyone who read the Figma multiplayer article and thought "that's kind of what I need" would be well served by Durable Objects, I think. https://www.figma.com/blog/rust-in-production-at-figma/

There are other approaches - I've worked in the past with CRDTs over WebRTC which felt absolutely space-age. But that's a much more complicated foundation compared to a websocket and a single class instance "somewhere" in the cloud.

View on HN

That's a very interesting use case. Given that your "players" aren't guaranteed to be local to the DO, doesn't using DOs only make sense in high-traffic situations again? Otherwise you might as well just serve the players from a conventional server, no?

CRDTs really do sound amazing, though.

In practice you’re most likely to be collaborating with other folks on your school project group, work team, close family, etc. Sure there are exceptions, but generally speaking picking a service location near your first group member ensures low latency for them (and they’re probably most engaged), and is likely to have lowish latency for everyone else.

On the flip side, picking US-East-1 gives okayish latency to folks near that, and nobody else.

And the corollary to that is that often your collaborations have a naturally low scale. While your entire app/customerbase as a whole needs to handle thousands of requests per second or more, one document/shard may only need to handle a handful of people.

Best case, the players are co-located in a city or country, and they'll benefit from data center locality.

Worst case, they're not co-located, and one participant has good latency, and the other doesn't. This is equivalent to the "deploy the backend in a single server/datacenter" approach.

Aside from the data locality, I still find the programming model (a globally-unique and addressable single-threaded class instance) to be quite nice, and would want to emulate it even without the Cloudflare edge magic.

> Aside from the data locality, I still find the programming model (a globally-unique and addressable single-threaded class instance) to be quite nice, and would want to emulate it even without the Cloudflare edge magic.

You might be interested in Plane (https://plane.dev/ / https://github.com/jamsocket/plane), which we sometimes describe as a sort of Durable Object-like abstraction that can run anywhere containers can.

(I'm also one of the articles you linked, thanks for the shoutout!)

I am interested, and I really enjoy your work on Browsertech! I haven't needed Plane above/over what Cloudflare is providing, but I've got it in the back of my mind as an option.

I've long hoped other providers might jump on the Durable Objects bandwagon and provide competing functionality so we're not locked in. Plane/Jamsocket looks like one way to go about mitigating that risk to a certain extent.

It's the actor model essentially.

You can have a DO proxy each user connection, then they forward messages to the multipler document. The user proxy deals with ordering and buffering their connection message state in the presence of disconnects, and the document DO handles the shared state.

It's actors plus a global routing system that means all messages addressed to a unique identifier will arrive in the actor instance. I haven't seen any other actor frameworks that provide that.

Akka and Erlang both support distributed routing to their actors, but this is planetary scale and fully-managed out of the box, which is very cool.

Some games have regions and you only see players in the same region. For example, a “Europe” region. If you’re in the US and you connect to the Europe region, you know that you should expect some lag.

And it seems like that would work just as well with durable objects.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com