Hacker News Reader

Comment by miki123211 | Hacker News Reader

> It has so many applications, among which is estimating number of clusters for a Gaussian mixture model

Any sources for that? As far as I remember, EM is used to calculate actual cluster parameters (means, covariances etc), but I'm not aware of any usage to estimate what number of clusters works best.

Source: I've implemented EM for GMMs for a college assignment once, but I'm a bit hazy on the details.

View on HN

you are right you still need the number of clusters

I've been out of the loop for stats for a while, but is there a viable approach for estimating ex ante the number of clusters when creating a GMM? I can think if constructing ex post metrics, i.e using a grid and goodness of fit measurements, but these feel more like brute forcing it

Unsupervised learning is hard, and the pick K problem is probably the hardest part.

For PCA or factor analysis, there's lots of ways but without some way of determining ground truth it's difficult to know if you've done a good job.

Is the question fundamentally: what's the relative likelihood of each number or clusters?

If so then estimating the marginal likelihood of each one and comparing them seems pretty reasonable?

(I mean in the sense of Jaynes chapter 20.)

There are Bayesian nonparametric methods that do this by putting a dirichlet process prior on the parameters of the mixture components. Both the prior specification and the computation (MCMC) are tricky, though.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com