> This claim is hard to reconcile with the CDC's official numbers which show a typical life expectancy for the entire area
Buettner's focus was on the outliers. Loma Linda is a longevity hotspot, and the question is why.
He found the long-living outliers practiced certain behaviors that they associated with Adventism, like vegetarianism.
Not all Adventists practice those behaviors. About half of Adventists eat meat, for example.
But the long-living outliers were Adventist and practiced the behaviors that he highlighted. So that was his takeaway.
By focusing on the older people only in such a small population, he is introducing selection bias and survivorship bias. Moreover, he did not control or compare studies. I believe there are more than one Adventist community in the US, yet those are not Blue Zones somehow?