Hacker News Reader

Comment by Animats | Hacker News Reader

How's Open Worm coming along? The connectome of C. Elegans has been known for years, and Open Worm tries to simulate it. [1] Not with enormous success.

[1] https://openworm.org/assets/OpenWormPoster_Celegans_Glasgow_...

View on HN

Like everything in science: we don't know until we know.

No need to treat research like a business.

Budgets are finite, and most science funding involves some decision making about how to allocate resources.

And you can't know where to allocate resources best until after the science is done (unless a field/group is known to scam).

Although for what we know now, we definitely can't understand the territory without a map.

It’s a non-profit volunteer run project. People spend more money on stamp collections.

You know you would have thought all the years and years of "donations" to "cancer research" there would be constant news stories about how we accidentally cured a bunch of ancillary medical problems, and wow its all free to everyone because it was from donations!

Never heard a single story like this

Human Genome Project and everything derived from it. IIRC, that was originally proposed as a cancer research project:

"A Turning Point in Cancer Research: Sequencing the Human Genome" - https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.3945817

Even without that I'm not sure why you think that's a good point — it's very easy to find serendipitous examples in medicine in general, e.g. viragra which was initially a heart treatment, or even thalidomide whose anti-cancer uses were suggested by the very birth defects that made it infamous.

Specifically cancer research finding other things by accident:

"Cancer researchers accidentally discover ‘cure’ for baldness, gray hair" - https://technology.inquirer.net/62453/cancer-researchers-acc...

"Cancer Researchers Accidentally Discover New Nylon Process" - https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/health/a8135/cancer...

Was there any "productionization" of the "cure" for baldness & gray hair, after it was discovered 7 years ago? I reckon, there's a huge market for that cure.

https://perfecthairhealth.com/why-krox20-isnt-a-miracle-hair...

“We were just doing cancer research and … we accidentally found the cure for homosexuality" (The Onion)[1]

[1] https://theonion.com/scientists-don-t-get-mad-but-we-acciden...

I mean I get this is a joke, but it's still homophobic at its core, imo. Why riff on the same on argument against homosexuality when it would've been much more humorous to "turn it around" and joke about finding a cure for heterosexuality and research indicating that homosexuality should be the de facto state.

Tho tbf when I've joked about that with str8 friends they get really upsetti spaghetti, yet somehow still can't link their spaghettiness to why I was offended when they said "just don't act gay" when I said I would love to see Egypt but didn't want to travel there.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com