We're building a statue of Aaron Swartz | Hacker News Reader

We're building a statue of Aaron Swartz

aaronstatue.org

96 pointspablopeniche25 comments

This looks like a scam. They’re asking for $5k - 20k individual donations for a statue that (according to the supposed sculptor’s website) will only cost $6,000.

https://www.monumentallabs.co/commissions

Why are they asking for so much money?

Also, the website claims that donations are tax-deductible, but there’s no mention of a registered non-profit organization.

No transparency. So many questions.

Hey thetopher, I'm the guy building the statue. My name is Pablo Peniche (@pablopeniche on twitter). I'm happy to put my name on it and answer questions.

The cost of the bigger-than-life-size statue (about 1.3x) is ~$25,000 (I'm happy to show you the receipts) Shipping is ~$6,000 (it's "art" shipment so it's more expensive). + Installation at the park + Permits from city gov + Costs of the unveiling event

A 501c3 (not my own, but a tech-culture magazine "The Mars Review of Books") is sponsoring the project, so yea all donations are tax deductible.

I've personally paid ~$10,000 (again, I'm happy to show receipts) to get the design of the statue + website - and I made it all open-source so anyone can 3D print their own statue, for free.

Let me know if you have more questions.

Hi Pablo, I agree w/ thetopher that this needs more transparency. If you're happy to show your receipts to date, you should do so on the website. Also, offer a way to contact you (email, phone, something) that isn't twitter.

I'd like receipts publicly posted as well.

What is the purpose behind hiding the statue's location?

Aloha Pablo. Aaron was a mentor to me and one of my "heroes" (as much as one can have heros). My greatest regret in life is not being brave enough to stand up with him when he was under attack. I've cried about that often.

I'd love to help you out.

1-415-937-1984

breck7@gmail.com

The $6000 number is just for a bust

Interestingly, this won’t be his first statue. He is among the statues at the Internet archive. https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Aaron_Swartz_statu... See also - https://www.nualacreed.com/galleries/ceramic-archivists

I've been wanting to endow a chair at the Mechanics Institute Library named after Aaron. Those have apparently gone up to $500 recently, but that still has to be a lot cheaper than a professorship at Stanford or anyplace like that:

https://www.milibrary.org/chair-appeal

My idea is to place it near the computer terminals in the library, so you could sit in it and send out job application emails starting "I currently occupy the Aaron Swartz endowed chair at the San Francisco Mechanics' Institute...". Heh.

We're building a statue of Aaron Swartz.

Our internet is under threat, once again.

The marble bust, to be installed in a public park in SF, will remind us of our internet values: freedom of speech, freedom of access, and privacy.

RSVP for the unveiling on Nov 8th (Aaron's birthday) in SF and DONATE! – http://aaronstatue.org

> Carved in marble, to be installed in a public park in [UNDISCLOSED], San Francisco

Isn’t it unusual to censor the location, wouldn’t this be public information anyone could request from the city?

In my city, in New Zealand, this would have been discussed in committee meetings along with mountains of paperwork and health and safety documents.

The RSVP as an image that might be a render of the statue or bust:

https://lu.ma/qasq8c6u

Maybe it's a way of saying that they don't know where yet (permissions etc.)?

Or that they don't intend to get permission.

JSTOR is a disgrace. RIP Aaron Swartz.

I'm not good with names and forgot who he was. I think the website should have given a short reminder.

He is a famous activist behind the Creative Commons. Died too young in 2013 at the age of 26. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aaron_Swartz

Or you could RTFA...

He put his own life on the line to liberate scientific information for us all: https://x.com/breckyunits/status/1839806663752331535

A documentary: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M85UvH0TRPc

Would a better tribute be something that's directly related to appropriate internet activism, and not physically tied to a single location that few will ever see/visit/care about?

This can be widely publicized, and IMHO, should be. That's a start.

It's a tragedy when someone commits suicide. I am in favor of open access to scientific literature.

But I don't think he's a hero, and I don't think he deserves a statue.

Aaron is the Martyr of our revolution. He deserves this and much more. It's a total disgrace that the Reddit IPO Prospectus failed to even mention his name.

Aaron Swartz should be remembered but afaik he committed suicide.

As someone with a failed attempt, I hope this doesn't set an example for others to an hero.

You skipped part of the story friend.

Am I too stupid to donate ? Pressing the button only opens a mail form...

this man should be remembered by the younger generations

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Q6Fzbgs_Lg

Who is we?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com