Hacker News Reader

Well, it isn’t great. Computers are logic, and LLM tools are not really able to derive logic from language.

Is there is enough logic q&a yeah they manage to produce something like what people talk about.

My experience with this has been terrible, I find them useless.

monsieur, what good is a new-born baby?

LLMs are not intellence. They are not AGI. They do not have the reasoning skills of a baby. This is not something they will "grow into". No amount of additional training data in the world will turn LLMs into AGI. Any argument to the contrary is pure, 100% copium to justify the hundreds of billions of dollars industry has poured into this technology.

hot air balloons aren't birds either, monsieur

That analogy still doesn't mean LLMs are a form of intelligence with reasoning capability.

it also doesn't mean sulfur is a metal

If and when you try to derive logic from the statistical model that is an LLM, you will face the same problem that Bertrand Russel did.

Good luck.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com