I pay for Hulu. If I start seeing ads after paying >$20/month for it, why would I pay for it instead of torrenting web rips?
Edit: I’m trying to be reasonable, you know? Services cost money, this is fair; have to pay COGS for everyone involved to get the bits to my devices. But the relationship is always in tension. I can go without, I can source the content elsewhere, etc. But mess it (the experience, broadly speaking) up and I will bail, you are competing with free. Disney owns Hulu and they’re are doing just fine financially (~$174B market cap, ~$90B/year in revenue). Don't mess it up, I want to give you money if I am getting value.
Time for a new tier. Limited ads.