Hacker News Reader

Comment by Loughla | Hacker News Reader

I had the same question. Anyone from Ireland here that might have any idea at all what that's about?

Idk about this specific thing, but this is much simpler than it sounds if it operates like other anthropology. Ritualistic means intentional, and supernatural means symbolically meaningful. In other words, this is less of a specific claim and more of an "idk but they were clearly up to something".

The problem is how it's written, I think.

I now understand what you're saying, but the way it's phrased in the article makes it seem like they need to know where it came from for ritualistic and supernatural reasons. Like there are rituals the anthropologists have to perform, not that they might have ritualistic use in the past.

It's a weirdly written sentence.

Or maybe I've just been awake for too long.

You are not wrong. The Guardian made an absolute hash of it. I recommend that you read the original document which says this: “However, to fully understand and appreciate these artifacts, it's crucial to know the exact location where they were found. The context of such discoveries helps archaeologists piece together ancient settlement patterns and cultural practices. For instance, hoards or collections of objects were often deliberately placed in specific locations for reasons that could range from ritualistic to supernatural.”

Here is the link: https://www.museum.ie/en-IE/News/Appeal-for-information-abou...

I interpret supernatural to mean religious in this context. I don't think this find will take on an X-Files direction.

> I interpret supernatural to mean religious in this context.

TBH I have no clue what the word "religious" means outside of abrahamic faiths. Might as well be a meaningless word. Anyway, the supernatural certainly encompasses many aspects of religion without implying anything about aliens.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com