I believe that these things work. But I for one don't want more years as a wage slave, particularly when coupled with anhedonia. Sure, I'll extract more value for my corporate overlords, but what's in it for me? For some definition a long life without any pleasure is an optimization, but I'd argue the validity of this definition.
I want a future where people aren't dying of cancer, cardiovascular disease, losing limbs and eyes to diabetes, getting strokes and where they're living long and healthy lives. I don't really care so much about the means. GLP-1s are the only proven non-surgical intervention that allows people to lose a clinically significant (>5%) amount of weight and keep it off long-term (>5 years).
Prior to Iodized salt, Switzerland was suffering from a rash of people with Goiter, which is disfiguring and decreases your quality of life, and also a large population with cretinism which causes stunted growth and mental retardation.
Then, they introduced iodized salt, and those issues which used to be somewhat prevalent only 100 years ago are practically nonexistent now.
https://swissfederalism.ch/en/100-years-salt-iodination-swit...
The hard way of finding out how bad polished white rice is for you - https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/rice-disease-mystery-e...
There are many companies making different versions of this drug, I don't see why you think its some kind of conspiracy intended to control the masses, literally if the benefit is greater than the costs what is your issue with it?
https://www.fractyl.com/fractyl-health-demonstrates-signific...
https://recursiveadaptation.com/p/the-growing-scientific-cas...
> The consistency that I'm hearing from all across patient groups is gain of control, whereas previously, there was a loss of control… All of a sudden they're able to step back and say, 'oh, well I had this shopping phenomenon that was going on, gambling, addiction, or alcoholism, and all of a sudden, it just stopped,' -- Dr. Gitanjali Srivastava, Vanderbilt Medical Center
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40357197 (comment from u/comova)
> 1. GLP-1 drugs appear to dramatically reduce addictive drive across substances. 2. GLP-1 drugs can reach vastly more patients than existing medications and they have positive mental health benefits for anxiety and depression. 3. This is our first ever opportunity to make a big dent in the addiction crisis, which kills 770,000 people a year between opioids, cigarettes, and alcohol.
If it's a net positive to my life what is the problem?
You have a very dismal view of the world, it is possible to enjoy one's work, or at least tolerate it, or work for yourself in the current economic system. Personally I appreciate the improved standard of living I have thanks to the efficiency of our profit driven system.
Immediately after going on metformin my appetite calmed. Slowly, over the next year, I lost 25 pounds. I did not try to diet. My BMI is now 23.7.
After a few months I started weight training. I changed my diet to lower carbs. I haven't lowered my HbA1c into a totally comfortable level (it is 5.6 and 5.7 and above is prediabetic). But I am better.
But before any of those changes, just the Metformin alone calmed my appetite. I can go hours without thinking about food. I am just less concerned. I feel normal.
Just as a data point, the last time I got Covid, it was quite mild. It's at least possible that the better metabolic health and weight loss had an impact.