Comment by 1oooqooq | Hacker News Reader

Comment by 1oooqooq | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

Not so.

Google <stores> most of your data. If you have your tax records on gdrive, google so far cannot target ads based on that content (i can't say forsure if you attach your tax form in gmail nowadays)

With SOLID any site can simply say "we need your tax records to prove you're a human or combat fraud whatever".

SOLID and all other not-solutions like it make your consent as useless as android app permissions. Accept a huge list they don't even bother to show anymore or go away.

Remember how android 2.3 you still could deny internet access permission? With SOLID it will be the same. Full ID data will eventually move to expandable list of permissions you will give by default.

I bet benners thought very hard about all the math and network etc. But he's being a buffoon when it comes to understanding applicability.

> With SOLID any site can simply say "we need your tax records to prove you're a human or combat fraud whatever".

This is not true. But there are human factors issues to solve. Personal AI will help.

Most of what google &c possess is inference and real-time metadata, which is the real dark magic. Giving people precise control over their identity and information via standards will be a huge gain, but it's not an easy task.

You just highlighted how the narrative really coopt smart people into not seeing the externalities.

Companies will drag this forward anyway. Apple into their proprietary tent, everyone else in every direction they can. It's a very legitimate role of government to try to put some controls on this mess, and the ideas behind those controls is a better next generation system.

THAT'S why I hammer the point he is being a useful idiot.

He is doing their work and trying to force regulations that are good for that terrible end state. He's working so that government help it, not put some controls, which we already have today btw

You can't put controls around grey goo. You can put controls around clearly defined access methods and data shapes.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com