Hacker News Reader

Comment by judge2020 | Hacker News Reader

judge2020

I was able to get pretty close with chatgpt: https://rr.judge.sh/Commabutterfly/76b34e/nmwguWGt8pIe.jpg

> create a picture of scrabble pieces strewn on a table, with a closeup of a line of scrabble letters spelling "CHATGPT" on top of them. photographic, realistic quality, maintain realism and believability

View on HN

You can get much better results with Ideogram 2 (also free):

https://ideogram.ai/assets/image/lossless/response/vF81gKjHS...

https://ideogram.ai/assets/image/lossless/response/EcRpDLumS...

Almost the same prompt.

Great tip. The text handling here is far superior.

The “1”s are still inconsistent, and of course the numbers are all wrong.

This seems like a good idea for a contest.

You can also get reasonably close with an open model that you can run locally (flux dev).

https://replicate.com/p/xm41nvz05drm00chsywb6am7f0

https://replicate.com/p/kdw8bnkj39rm40chsyzbyg5e04

But of course anyone who has even a passing familiarity with scrabble is going to be able to tell that something's off.

The biggest problem with the default Flux model is that it generates images with that strong AI look, probably caused by the distillation of the CFG. You should try some LoRAs for this, and also prompt the model to generate the rack that holds the letters.

Good point. I have a comfyui setup for it but its super basic right now just the diffusion model / clip loader / vae. Another thing you've probably noticed is that 99% of images from Flux tend to have that classic narrow depth of field look. I've seen people occasionally be able to get around it with pretty amusing prompt tokens like "instagram photo, selfie, gopro, etc." though.

The number markings on the Scrabble pieces are nonsensical, the wooden ground looks like plastic, there are strange artifacts like the white smudge on the edge of the “E” tile in the front, and so on.

AI-generated images are clearly identifiable as such, and it just gets annoying to continually see those desultory fabrications.

I prefer yours. Better lighting.

The points on all the tiles are messed up and there are tiles with random squiggles where there should be letters...

Reply on news.ycombinator.com