I fully agree with him on Apple. The current App Store rules are insanely anti-competitive. It is as if Microsoft would launch Windows 12 where all software, I mean apps, had to be downloaded and purchased (30% goes to MS) via the Microsoft store. Valve's Steam would be forbidden, browsers other than Edge as well.
Not really the same because Microsoft isn't the sole manufacturer of Windows devices
How would that be relevant?
A better comparison: what if Comcast required you to pay 5% of your income to use their Internet. After all, you can always switch, right?
A broken clock may be right twice a day, but it's still a broken clock.