Hacker News Reader

Comment by mullingitover | Hacker News Reader

I got the last good macbook--the first 13-inch unibody, with a trivially replaceable battery and hard drive. Wish Apple would've kept that design around, it's fantastic.

View on HN

How often do you replace the battery and hard drive?

In the life of my 2008 MBP, I replaced the battery twice and the HDD three times (died mechanical failure once, second time became an SSD).

Maybe more often than you would expect. Don't SSDs have a higher failure rate than their spinning metal counterparts?

at least once?

I have the same laptop and replaced the battery last year and also upgraded to a SSD. This made my old 2ghz C2D just as fast in everyday tasks at the i5 air I got from work.

in other news I just ordered a new MBP Retina to replace it :)

As many times as he wants, he bought a computer.

I had a late 2007 white MacBook whose original battery was still marginally usable last year (the menu status was Replace Soon, rather than Replace Now) - holding about 60% nominal charge, IIRC. The drive had been replace once, following an overheating incident which left it failing.

I have a six-year-old 15" MacBook Pro, which is now on its third battery. A year or so ago the original 120GB hard drive started making ticking sounds, and I replaced it with a 500GB drive (not SSD - at today's prices I would have gone for a 256GB SSD). It's still a perfectly capable machine - a bit constrained by being limited to 3GB of RAM, but otherwise fine.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com