Hacker News Reader

Comment by paul7986 | Hacker News Reader

Took about 15 to 20 flights in 2023 and the best experience was Spirit (majority were Spirit out of their hubs); pack things in bookbag, put bookbag under seat, get off plane quickly and saved 1,000s cumulatively.

United was the worst due to someone smelling up the plane & they didnt clean the bathroom .. made everyone gag.

Everyone hates on Spirit but if you're a frequent traveler who flies lite and likes to travel a lot/ not spend a lot they rock . If you are expecting same level of svc as more expensive airlines then you should spend that extra money.

View on HN

I like Ryanair for similar reasons. "Premium" airlines give you a bit more leg room, but that extra space is filled up with pouch and useless magazines.

Budget airlines are in some way better organized and streamlined. For example they do not allow dogs on board, like at all :-)

On Delta the pockets are falling apart because they don’t maintain their cabins very well

Feels like a very specific anecdote. There is no reason Spirit planes won't smell or United planed always will.

If you travel light, perhaps that includes the passengers bowels too xD

Seriously, spirit is like taking a bus. Either you have no experience or a bad one. It’s just to get somewhere cheap. Seats are bad, nickel and dime for everything, customer service is as barebones as it gets.

Spirit is a school Chromebook. It works, don’t ask much from it.

I on the other hand had the best experiences flying 10-12h flights with both delta and United. United has served me the best foods out of us airlines (butter chicken, perfect food to let it sit in a warm tray, NOT PASTA everyone else. If someone from the food dept of flights reads this, stop it with the disgusting pasta on flights).

And delta has always been very easy for me, flight attendants are pleasant and any time I’ve been delayed they have automatically found me a flight without me having to actually call them out. The app is nice, WiFi works, seats are good. The main con is that their hub is Atlanta and that airport is a rats nest.

I got upgraded to business class on a Haneda to O'Hare United flight. That flight wasn't long enough ..

Rather off-topic, but when you wrote:

>Seriously, spirit is like taking a bus.

I thought to myself "ah, a decent airline then, not as bad as others in this comment section describe it", and only at your next sentence did I remember that in the US, public transit seems to suffer from really bad reputation (probably due to serious underfunding). You really need to get this sorted out, life's so much better with good public transport :)

(It's far from perfect in my country, and I'm often annoyed by it, but it seems to be nonexistent or only used by the truely desperate in many US cities, at least in the public perception)

You must be thinking of long distance buses, not the inner city transit. The one in my city is IMO the best in the US, yet I want more of my flights (unless I’m flying for one hour, which I don’t think should be the standard by which an airline is evaluated)

That's cool you have the money to fly frequently on more expensive airlines. Im only sharing my experiences flying Spirit out of their hubs and they have been no different then flying on the more expensive airliners outside of seats could use more cushion on Spirit but no biggie at all on five to six hour flights with them.

As noted in my comment you want your flight experience to be of a higher grade then continue to enjoy to fly the more expensive airlines. Sounds like you can afford doing so and frequently so. Myself i like being cheap in terms of getting from point A to point B .. have more money to spend on hotel room and or overall more trips in a year. I'm not rich and extremely happy to fly with other middle class people and frequently so!

Your comment implied other airlines are worse because of two anecdotes. You simply like spirit because it’s cheaper, and that’s ok. It has nothing to do with me not wanting to mix up with “other middle class people”. Somehow you assume I’m not middle class because I stated that Spirit is very basic.

Also I just happens to be looking at flights and the difference between Sprit and American is minimal. Add a carryon to Spirit and it might be over the American flight.

Cool myself clothes and travel stuff in a bookbag and Im good..5 day trips.. my friend hooked me up with a vaccuum seal bag.

Sure yet Spirit's planes are newer and smaller then that huge old United plane (Boeing... Spirit uses Airbus) where the bathroom sat in the middle of the plane. THe stenched was not cleaned up and being in the middle of the plane affected way more people then bathroom in the back of the plane affecting only a few of the rows in the back.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com