Hacker News Reader

Comment by tanelpoder | Hacker News Reader

But if the Azure outage is due to Windows machines crashing because of the currently ongoing CrowdStrike crash/reboot loop issue, then such servers might end up being down in all regions. Looks like there might be some advanced lessons to be learned about blast radius here...

View on HN

Azure VM host machines are running CrowdStrike...??

Maybe because Windows Defender Advanced Threat Protection is an enormous resource hog that scans every byte of memory and storage accessed by the Hypervisor and performs a quadratic time computation on the data? I am just guessing because my “fastest” Windows laptop CPU money could buy feels like a hot smelting furnace and a sloth at the same time when I use VMWare Workstation. What the &$@* is it scanning the VMWare guests for?

Oh, Crowdstrike is also a massive resource hog.

Probably not, but maybe they rely on some Active Directory server that is running it?

VM storage is probably on Windows Server, plus AD. I'd bet out of band management is all in the impact zone too. Might be back to someone pushing physical switches and hooking up a KVM.

And this explains why the (Linux) HPC that I'm using is having so many troubles today, and keeps complaining that I don't exist.

IF they're running windows, they'll be running it.

More likely crash looping of so many VMs overloading some system with insufficient back pressure, possibly combined with unfortunate cluster management scheduler behavior at this scale of crash looping (e.g. too eager to retry scheduling instances, maybe even on new hosts which causes more infrastructure load).

It's more coincidental than likely, since these are managed services that were down, while the crowdstrike issue is closer to company deployments.

But never say impossible, it's best to wait and see what the actual problem is rather than throwing shade so early.

Update. Throw shade. They've confirmed it. I was wrong.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com