How AI Is Enhancing, Not Replacing, Human Expertise in Creative Fields
blog.scottynordstrom.org
blog.scottynordstrom.org
We have:
- A song that the AI wrote, without any explanation of how it assisted a musician, instead of just creating a song from scratch
- An image, which was again totally generated. There's a bit of text about how artists will imbue the image with "personal experience", whatever that means; I guess that means photoshopping some stuff onto it?
- A poem, which is just bad, and which again was written from whole cloth without any explanation of how AI assisted anyone.
LLMs are bringing the same thing, at a much different level, to the playing field. LLMs aren't perfect (and neither was what we had before) but it accelerates our ability to deliver in a way that many technological innovations have before us.
They will NOT replace us, at least not for the foreseeable future; however, the incremental shift on access to information, closer-to-done status, and creative inspiration (developers, administrators, writers, and artists alike) will cause a massive shift in how we work day to day.
In this example, it's not an assistant - it created the entire poem, doing the entirety of the work. That's like saying my local handyman is an "assistant" when he built our entire deck.
A hammer is a tool to most, but a weapon to some
The problem is, the desire and means to lazily or cynically profit and misinform outweigh the positive applications here.
I also believe Brandolini's Law will be a major problem, though not necessarily an impossible one
> The amount of energy needed to refute bullshit is an order of magnitude bigger than that needed to produce it.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandolini%27s_law
I believe the value of curators and editors will skyrocket in the future
I read Tabby McTat over and over to my granddaughter who never tired of it. I could recite most of it now.
AI is clearly enhancing humans in their creation of garbage.
There's gotta be a better way to phrase this. OP didn't write anything except a prompt.
So what is going to happen?
Well, if AI is doing all the thinking work, there’s no need for an education.
Education is already in free fall due to it being taken over by people who just want to maximize profits. This will make the problem worse.
And technology continues to isolate us and act as a conduit for whatever ideas spread the fastest- that means anything that triggers your amygdala.
A population with no jobs and no education and social connections is an angry and ignorant one. That means conservatism and conflict. Liberalism is the politics of trust. Conservatism is the politics of fear. And ignorant, isolated people are easy to manipulate.
And we in the USA live in a country flooded with guns.
The end of result of all that, in the past, has always been war. Maybe we’ll get lucky. I doubt it. There’s dry tinder piled up everywhere, and we are playing with matches.
It’s not gonna all fall apart this year. But, in 20, 30 years, with climate change and mass migration thrown into the mix, things are going to get bad.
Maybe. Maybe not. I doubt this quite a lot, personally, but I, like you, are merely speculating. We'll see what the future brings.