The original idea behind passive investing was to use the pooled intelligence of many traders guessing the value of cr I think we’re beyond that. Most traders are just trying to get a timing edge over the indices. This introduces the modern concept of passive investing as a positive feedback loop force-fed by monetary supply. The market seems to hate dividends and buybacks, preferring expansion or acquisition, but then what gives it value? It has to be its memetic ability to attract investment, and this can easily eclipse anything on the earnings statement. I’m not sure this can go on forever.