Hacker News Reader

Comment by kbos87 | Hacker News Reader

I agree with you with one exception, Dolores Claiborne is a gem of a film.

I think there's several exceptions. The Shawshank Redemption was fantastic for instance.

> The Shawshank Redemption was fantastic for instance.

Eh it comes off as a corny and flat depiction of people who might otherwise be interesting. Romantic, but not a depiction of believable humans. And the problem certainly ain't the actors.

I get that it's cool to dislike what's popular, but I don't think we've seen the same Shawshank Redemption film.

My criticism of Shawshank redemption is indeed particularly in response to it being placed number one on the IMDB list of greatest movies of all time. I believe people ranked it there as a result of emotional catharsis rather than ranking based on whether a movie best realized its potential, and I think my response is validated: the script for Shawshank redemption could have portrayed the characters as more three-dimensional than as recorded.

I've never read the book, but perhaps this criticism applies to the book as well. King certainly has a tendency to push fetishized characteristics that take the place of earnest characterization. This is certainly true of the Stand, the Dark Tower series, the Shining, Insomnia, Green Mile, and probably many others of his works. This is not an original take. See one popular opinion here: http://strangehorizons.com/non-fiction/articles/stephen-king...

I do not need to read an opinion to know what to think about The Shawshank Redemption. I can think for myself.

I like the movie, it's one of my favourite films of all time, and I am sorry you feel I and a large contingent of people are misguided because they have a different opinion than yours or your favourite critic's.

I have rewatched it in the past 6 months BTW.

Of course, many of King's stories do seem to push "fetishized characteristics" as you call them: in The Shining, Danny had the power to "shine". In Green Mile, the protagonist had a magical healing ability. But what characteristics did the characters in Shawshank have? Both seemed fairly well-rounded to me, and certainly didn't have any supernatural abilities (which is one thing that set Shawshank apart from many King stories).

Rob Reiner's Misery and Brian de Palma's Carrie are both excellent too.

Thanks! One of my favorite books of his. I didn't know that it was made into a movie too. Somehow I've missed it for the last 27 years.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com