Is it feasible for a regular American to keep their physical address private?
old.reddit.com
old.reddit.com
You can take it even further and authorize requests for verification. E.g., I can let my car insurance company see my zip code, or even just get a yes/no that I live in a specific zip code.
Source: am a lawyer.
Extreme privacy is extremely expensive and permanently lifestyle-altering.
Take your strategic and tactical cues from Cold War-era spycraft and from current-day hyperparanoid internet security practices.